PMU NAI International Patent Award Applicant Evaluation
Reviewer's Name
Email
Applicant Information
Applicant's Name
Is the applicant affiliated with an NAI Member Institution?
Yes
No
Does the applicant have an issued U.S. Patent?
Yes
No
Was there a Letter of Support enclosed with the application?
Yes
No
Innovation and Originality
Please rate the applicant on the following criteria. Nominees can earn up to 3 points per question. The highest possible score is 20.
Does the invention include one of the following categories? * (
2 points
)
Technology Applications
Engineering
Water and Food Security
Sustainability
Medicine
Life Science
Disruptive Business Models
Yes
No
Research and Development
Please rate the applicant on the following criteria. Nominees can earn up to 3 points per question.
The highest possible score is 20.
Does this invention address and solve a unique problem?
Please select...
Invention does solve a unique problem. (3 points)
Invention somewhat solves a unique problem. (2 points)
Invention does not solve a unique problem. (1 point)
Did the applicant clearly articulate the size and scope of this invention?
Please select...
Size and scope clearly articulated. (3 points)
Size and scope somewhat articulated. (2 points)
Size and scope were not articulated clearly. (1 point)
Invention Features
Please rate the applicant on the following criteria. Nominees can earn up to 3 points per question.
The highest possible score is 20.
Is this invention unique compared to existing solutions?
Please select...
Invention is unique (3 points)
Applicant compared invention to existing solutions (2 points)
Applicant did not compare with existing solutions (1 point)
Invention Applications
Please rate the applicant on the following criteria. Nominees can earn up to 3 points per question.
The highest possible score is 20.
Did the proposed invention description reflect products or services where the invention could be applied or implemented in practice?
Please select...
Invention reflects products or services that could be applied or implemented in practice. (3 points)
Invention somewhat reflects products or services that could be applied or implemented in practice. (2 points)
Invention does not reflect products or services that could be applied or implemented in practice. (1 point)
Commercial Interest
Please rate the applicant on the following criteria. Nominees can earn up to 3 points per question.
The highest possible score is 20.
Does this invention have the potential opportunity for commercialization?
Please select...
Invention has strong potential opportunity for commercialization. (3 points)
Invention has limited potential for commercialization. (2 points)
Invention has minimal potential for commercialization. (1 point)
Potential Impact
Please rate the applicant on the following criteria. Nominees can earn up to 3 points per question.
The highest possible score is 20.
Rate this invention's current or potential impact on the field or society.
Please select...
Invention has a high potential impact. (3 points)
Invention has limited potential impact. (2 points)
Invention has minimal potential impact. (1 point)